Case Study: Catering to Different Types of Wine Drinkers

In a previous blog, But I’m Not a Wine Connoisseur, I wrote about 6 different categories of wine drinkers.  In this blog, I will address some of the things that we have done in our store to cater to each category.

Back before I worked in my father’s store, I was very intimidated by wine.  I knew there was red and white and it got better with time (which is not even true for most wines), but that was the extent of my knowledge.  When I shopped for wine, I looked for cool names and labels and bought solely based on that.  I did not want any help because I didn’t even know what questions to ask.   Now when I go into a store shopping for wine, I am looking to try new wines.  I am looking for different countries/regions that I haven’t tried.  I am looking for value wines that are very good for the money.  I am looking to compare and contrast between other wines that I have had and learn more about each wine that I drink.  These are two opposite ends of the spectrum and were things that we needed to consider when we opened our wine store.

Shelf Talkers


One of the first New York State winery’s that we carried was the ever popular Bully Hill Vineyards.  As I was trying to learn more about the vineyard and their wines, I came across their shelf talkers.  They were pretty basic, but after a quick look, I realized that they “spoke” to several categories of wine consumers.  They listed the winery, grape type (or name in some cases), brief information about the growing conditions, food pairings and dry/sweet indicator.  I also noticed  many people in the store bought Bully Hill wines, because they could turn to the back of the bottle and get the same information that was on the shelf talker.

This was an “aha!” moment for me.  I decided to look at each category of consumer and create a shelf talker with this information in mind for every wine that we carried.  In that way, we could differentiate us from any competing wine stores in the area.

So I went back to my blog post, took a look at each type of consumer, and made a list of what they cared about or wanted when they were shopping for wine.

Overwhelmed: Doesn’t want to ask for help, generally knows basics (white/red, dry/sweet)

Satisfied Sippers: Buy same brands, know whether they like dry or sweet

Traditionalists: Buy established brands, pair food with fine for events.  May stick to a certain country/region

Savvy Shoppers: Looking for deals/value wines

Image Seekers: Like ratings, new wines

Enthusiasts: Like more background about where the wine came from and the vintage

Based on this criteria, we came up with the following shelf talker.  It contains the country/region of the wine, the winery name, wine name, vintage, grape(s), tasting notes, food pairing recommendations, dryness/sweetness indicator and a rating (if the wine is rated).

There are many positives that we have seen from doing this:


  • Both customers and our employees now have an easy way to see lots of information about each wine
  • Customers who prefer to browse on there own can compare wines on as they please without needing an employee to help them
  • Customers may be inclined to try new wines because they understand the dryness/sweetness and tastes of each wine
  • Customers can easily tell the country/region of the wine
  • Customers are given an idea of what food the wine goes with
  • Customers can be aware of ratings for various wines
  • Customers can tell we truly care about giving them a great wine experience.  It takes quite a bit of time and effort to sample each wine and put the information about the wine together on these cards.

In the end, we have been very happy with the response of these cards.  Customers are raving about how nice it is to have that information while they are shopping.  Additionally, we have seen a trend in customers browsing the store longer and purchasing more wines per transaction.

Wine of the Month


Another strategy that we have employed to to pick one or two wines and feature them as our “Wine of the Month.”  When a wine becomes the wine of the month, a few things happen:

  • We open a sample of that wine for customers to try
  • We create a one-page flyer to display next to the wine with lots of information about the wine
  • We offer a 20% discount on the wine


When deciding on our store layout, we had a few different options for organizing the wine:

  • Organize by country/region
  • Organize by type
  • Organize by color

We ended up using a combination of all three.

First, we organized by color.  We determined that most of our customers were going to first look at the wine by color, so we placed the white wines on one side and the red wines on the other.


From there, we grouped wines by grape type so they would be easy to find.  So within the “Whites”, we have “Riesling,” “Chardonnay,” “Sauvignon Blanc,” “Pinot Grigio,” and so on.

Finally, since our store is located so close to the Finger Lakes, there is a high demand for local New York State wines.  We decided to pull the NYS wines out and have them in their own section so it would be easy for customers to find.

We have been opened for ~6 months so far.  Each week we receive new customers and get a lot of positive feedback.  Many people really like the feel of the store.  They appreciate our knowledgeable and friendly staff and all of the information we have presented throughout the store.  Most of all, they love the feel.  We have received numerous comments on the natural wood racks.  Customers say they look much nicer than boxes stacked on the floor and some even say it feels like they are at a winery.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *